PART 2
The woman I buried was named Ellie Marsh.
She had a laugh that made strangers turn around in restaurants and a habit of narrating what our daughter would be like, long before she was born.
See more on the next page
“She’ll have your stubbornness and my sense of direction, which means she’ll be lost and refuse to admit it.”
We had the nursery painted and the name picked.
Grace. We were going to call her Grace.
I have not said that name out loud in eighteen years, and I am saying it now because the girls deserve to know their almost-sister had a name, and because Sadie, it turned out, had known it too, and it mattered.
When she and the baby d*ed, I gave her the locket to be buried in, or I thought I did.
Inside it was a photograph, cut small, of Ellie at seventeen holding a little girl of about four on her hip at a lake.
I had never known who the little girl was.
Ellie had told me once, vaguely, that she had a much younger sister she’d lost touch with, a sister raised mostly apart from her after their parents split, and she didn’t like to talk about it, and I had loved her enough not to push.
I was holding that locket in my kitchen, eighteen years later, with two eighteen-year-old girls watching me, and I did not understand how it had come out of a beach towel.
“Dad,” Chloe said. “The little sister in the photo. Her name was Sadie.”
Emma unfolded the second towel, and from its hem, carefully unpicked, she drew a letter, yellowed and worn soft from being read.
“Sadie was our mother,” Emma said. “Our birth mother. And she was Ellie’s little sister.”
The kitchen tilted.
I had to put both hands flat on the table.
Eighteen years of random chance, of a cruel coincidence I had made a fragile peace with, of telling myself the universe had handed me a mercy by accident, reorganized itself in front of me into something else entirely.
Not an accident.
A gift. Aimed. Delivered. Signed.
The twins I had raised for eighteen years, the two girls I had found by chance on a beach three states from my home, were the nieces of the woman I was going to marry.
“That’s not possible,” I said, though even as I said it, I was looking at Chloe’s chin, which I had always privately thought looked like someone’s, and now I knew whose. “I found you by accident. Theo drove me there on a whim. It was random.”
